I Play Rocky
November 11th, 2026
MOVIE: I PLAY ROCKY
STARRING: ANTHONY IPPOLITO, ANNASOPHIA ROBB, P.J. BYRNE, TOBY KEBBELL
DIRECTED BY: PETER FARRELLY
AMovieGuy.com’s RATING: 2 ½ STARS (Out of 4)
RATED: PG-13
RUN TIME: 128 MINUTES

There is much to discuss with Peter Farrelly’s crowd-pleasing film, I Play Rocky. From the perspective of sitting in a movie theater and enjoying a great story, this is destined to be a massive hit with audiences. It tells the story of how Sylvester Stallone refused to take no for an answer and ultimately powered his way toward making Rocky, a film that went on to win Best Picture. As a piece of cinema, however, I Play Rocky is a fascinating exercise, though not necessarily a work of art. The story is an incredible achievement of perseverance and success, and undoubtedly enjoyable, yet it feels like the kind of movie that might have worked better as a documentary. At times, it even left me itching to watch the original Rocky for the 100th time.
Right off the bat, the biggest highlight of I Play Rocky is Anthony Ippolito’s miraculous performance, playing Stallone to uncanny perfection. He has the hair, the look, the voice, the build, and the mannerisms of the Rambo actor down to the smallest detail. It’s downright eerie. We see Sly going from audition to audition, trying to land a role in a major motion picture, only to find opportunities to play thugs or cops. Still plugging away, Stallone takes a job at a movie theater selling tickets, where he meets his eventual wife, Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb). She encourages him to try his hand at writing screenplays, and it turns out Stallone has a knack for it.
Drawing inspiration from his own life, and with Sasha’s support, he writes Rocky. With a little luck, he manages to get the script into the hands of MGM producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell). The two recognize its potential and want to finance the project, provided they can attach a major Hollywood name to play the lead. That becomes the one sticking point for Stallone. This is his story, and he believes he is the only person who can play the title character.
Much of the film focuses on the behind-the-scenes process of making Rocky and the negotiations that ultimately determine whether Stallone will get his chance to play the character. Written by Peter Gamble and directed by Farrelly, the story is undeniably courageous. We watch Stallone demonstrate just how much he believes in himself, regardless of how high the offers get or how much money he is willing to walk away from. His perseverance and determination make the story of Rocky all the more meaningful. Stallone may never have boxed in his life, but, much like his relationship with his father (played by Matt Dillon), it’s easy to understand what drove him to succeed: an inability to let others get him down. Some might call it confidence; others might simply call it refusing to give up. No matter how many times a person hears no, I Play Rocky reminds us that some things are too sacred to let go of.
When I left the theater, I certainly felt joy and appreciation for Stallone’s story. But something continued to gnaw at me: in the end, this is a movie dressed up as a movie. It’s difficult to separate the fact that Ippolito, Farrelly, and the supporting cast are essentially crafting recreations, a cinematic form of cosplay, while telling a story that could be repeated with countless other films. Are these movies becoming our new cinematic universe? Will we eventually get a film about the making of Apocalypse Now? How about the making of Justice League? I hope not. I’d rather read about those productions, watch a documentary, or simply revisit the original movies.
All that said, I still think I Play Rocky succeeds in delivering an entertaining and uplifting story. Most of the praise belongs to Ippolito, whose performance is nothing short of uncanny. I even caught myself wondering whether there would eventually be a movie about the making of I Play Rocky itself. A Russian nesting doll of a film, highlighting how Anthony Ippolito came out of nowhere and delivered such a remarkable performance as Sylvester Stallone. Maybe he should just re-create Stallone’s entire filmography. I’d love to see him take on Cobra, Rhinestone, or even Over the Top. Either way, he certainly knows how to play Rocky. I Play Rocky lands a punch. I’m just not so sure I want it to be a hit.
2 ½ STARS
I PLAY ROCKY IS PLAYING IN THEATERS EVERYWHERE FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20TH, 2026.
Written by: Leo Brady




